You Pay Absolutely Nothing Unless We Win Your Case
Most injury claims against a store, landlord or property owner turn on one fact: what the owner knew about the danger. A premises liability lawyer at Williams Caputo spends the early weeks of a case answering that question with records, video and witnesses. A wet floor, a broken stair, a dark parking lot and an unfenced pool all raise it.
People call these cases slip and falls, but that name is too small. The same rules reach a collapsed staircase, a dog attack in an apartment yard, a shooting in an unlit lot and a child who climbs into a pool. The law looks at the property and the owner’s choices, not at the way you went down.
Four things have to line up. The defendant owned or controlled the property, a dangerous condition existed, the owner knew or should have known about it, and that condition caused your injury.
Knowledge is where most cases are won or lost. In Albertsons, LLC v. Mohammadi (2024), the Texas Supreme Court said a visitor must prove the owner had actual or constructive knowledge of a condition that posed an unreasonable risk of harm.
Actual knowledge means the owner knew. Constructive knowledge means the condition sat there long enough that a reasonable inspection would have caught it.
The same decision limited an older Texas case, Corbin v. Safeway (1983). The court said Corbin applies, if at all, only where the owner had a policy or practice it knew routinely created an unreasonable risk.
Knowing that freezers can leak is not the same as knowing this freezer was leaking. That gap decides cases.
So we ask for records a visitor never sees. Inspection logs, cleaning schedules, staff schedules, prior incident reports, repair requests and camera footage can show how long a hazard sat and who walked past it.
The law does not treat every visitor the same, and the states disagree on how much that should matter.
Colorado’s Premises Liability Act (C.R.S. 13-21-115) sorts visitors into three groups. A judge decides which group you fit, and the jury decides fault and damages.
A trespasser can recover only for harm the owner caused willfully or deliberately. A licensee, such as a social guest, has a claim when the owner created a danger and actually knew of it, or knew of a danger it did not create and failed to warn about it.
An invitee is someone on the land for business or in answer to a public invitation. The owner must use reasonable care against dangers it actually knew of or should have known of.
New Mexico took a simpler path. In Ford v. Board of County Commissioners (1994), the state supreme court ended the old split between licensees and invitees. An owner or occupant now owes reasonable care to every entrant except trespassers, and a visitor’s status is only one factor.
The jury instruction on a visitor’s safety says the owner must use ordinary care to keep the property safe for the visitor’s use, and it can reach dangers that are obvious.
Texas applies the invitee rule described above to people who come onto property for the owner’s business.
In some settings the duty drops. Chapter 75 of the Civil Practice and Remedies Code covers agricultural land and recreational visitors. An owner it protects owes no more than trespasser-level care, which means avoiding willful, wanton or grossly negligent acts (75.002, 75.007). A narrow exception protects a child hurt by a highly dangerous artificial condition if five listed conditions are met.
We do not summarize Arizona’s visitor categories here. Those rules come from court decisions, and we check the current ones for each claim. The fault and deadline rules later on this page come from Arizona statutes.
Stores and restaurants are the familiar settings. Spills, wet floors, loose mats, cluttered aisles and broken carts all cause falls. Parking lots add potholes, bad lighting and poor drainage.
Apartment complexes and rental homes bring a different set of problems. Broken stairs and railings, rotted balconies, mold, faulty locks and unlit lots can all hurt people who have no choice about where they live.
When a crime happens on the property, the claim is about security, often called negligent security. We look at whether the owner knew about prior break-ins or assaults and still left a gate broken or a light out. Colorado’s premises statute adds a legislative statement on crimes by third parties. It questions earlier rulings that ignored whether the crime was the predominant cause of the harm (13-21-115).
Pools and play areas matter most for children. Colorado keeps the attractive nuisance rule for children under 14. New Mexico’s jury instruction asks whether the owner knew children were likely to trespass and whether the child was too young to see the risk.
Premises claims are one branch of personal injury law, and some injuries cross into other branches. A gunshot on someone else’s land can raise both a property question and a gun-handling question, which we cover under our accidental shooting cases. A dog attack in a yard or a hallway can involve the dog’s owner and the landlord, and we handle it as a dog bite claim. If someone dies, the family may bring a wrongful death claim with its own deadlines and its own rules about who may sue.
What you do in the first days can decide whether the owner’s knowledge can ever be proved.
The owner’s lawyer will say the spill was in plain view, the stairs were well lit, or the sign was posted. Each of those points is an attempt to shift blame onto you.
Whether it works depends on where you fell. Texas ends the claim above 50 percent fault (CPRC 33.001), and Colorado ends it once your share equals the owner’s (13-21-111). Arizona and New Mexico only cut your award by your percentage (A.R.S. 12-2505, Scott v. Rizzo). On a premises claim, photos of the lighting and the missing warning sign often decide how much blame sticks.
Several parties often share blame on a property. A store, its cleaning contractor and a landlord may each own part of the problem.
Arizona and New Mexico generally make each defendant pay only its own share (12-2506 and 41-3A-1). Texas does the same unless a defendant is more than 50 percent at fault (33.013). In Colorado, a defendant can name a nonparty at fault within 90 days after the case begins (13-21-111.5), so we check early who else should be sued.
A worker hurt on land that someone else owns may have a claim against the owner, apart from workers’ compensation. Texas sets a high bar when the worker was hurt by an improvement the contractor was building or repairing. Under Chapter 95, the owner is not liable unless it controlled how the work was done and had actual knowledge of the danger and failed to warn (CPRC 95.003). A June 2026 Texas Supreme Court decision, JMI Contractors v. Medellin, pushes the same direction. It put an independent contractor’s roof-edge fall in the premises category, so the knowledge rules above apply to that worker too.
The full rules for job-site injuries sit on our page about construction accident claims.
A fall in a private store and a fall on a city sidewalk start different clocks. Against a government owner, written notice comes first, and the notice deadline is much shorter than the lawsuit deadline.
A child’s deadline can run differently, and that matters for pool and playground cases. Texas does not count the years a person is under 18 (CPRC 16.001), and Arizona has a similar rule (A.R.S. 12-502). Colorado pauses the clock only when a child has no legal guardian or representative. New Mexico gives a person who was a minor or incapacitated one year after the incapacity ends (37-1-10).
A property case is built around one address, so the courthouse usually follows that address. A fall in a Lubbock store points to the Lubbock County Courthouse at 904 Broadway, where the 99th District Court sits in Suite 322. An injury at a Denver apartment building goes through the Denver City & County Building, 1437 Bannock Street.
Hospital records belong in the file too. A bad fall can mean head, spine and hip injuries, and the chart records what you said about how you fell, hours before any lawyer was involved. Dell Seton Medical Center at The University of Texas in Austin and Centura Health-St. Anthony Hospital in Lakewood are both on their state’s Level I trauma lists. Whichever hospital treats you, ask for the records early.
Start with the results. The firm lists a $5.3 million Texas premises liability verdict, which means a jury or judge decided that case after a trial. It also lists a $6 million result for a catastrophic injury at a Texas construction site, which is also an injury on land someone else controlled.
Property rules change at the state line, and Burgess Williams, a founding attorney, is admitted in all four states this page covers. His bio lists Super Lawyers Texas Rising Star recognition in 2019 and 2020. It also lists orthopedic injuries among his focus areas, and broken hips and shattered wrists are common after a fall.
Kieran Hillis earned his Texas bar license in 2016 and previously served in the Office of the Texas Attorney General and the Office of the Governor. Joe Caputo, a founding attorney, was on the Mock Trial Team and the Board of Advocates at St. Mary’s University School of Law, where he graduated in 2011. Spanish speakers can work directly with Burgess Williams or Jesús Salinas.
Past results do not guarantee a similar outcome. Every property case depends on what the owner knew and when.
A grocery store is a private owner, so the ordinary clock applies, and in Texas and Arizona that is two years. A city sidewalk is different. You must send written notice first, and it can be due in 90 days in New Mexico.
In Texas, yes. You must show the store had actual or constructive knowledge, meaning it knew or the spill sat there long enough to be found. In 2024 the Texas Supreme Court narrowed an older rule that sometimes helped customers. Video and inspection logs are often the best proof.
Yes, as long as someone owns or controls that spot. It could be a store, a landlord, a city or a contractor. A claim against a city or county has short notice deadlines.
Maybe. The owner will say you should have seen the hazard, but a hidden spill or a broken step is still the owner’s problem. Your share of blame lowers your award in every state, and in Texas and Colorado a large enough share ends the claim.
Call before you sign anything. A signed release usually ends the claim, even if your medical bills keep growing. We can review the offer for free.
The owner’s insurer starts building its file the day you fall, and the store’s cameras keep recording over the footage. Start yours by calling 512.351.7000 at any hour and giving us the address, the owner’s name if you know it, and the date. Talking to us costs nothing, and you pay no fee unless we win your case. We have offices in Austin, Denver and Phoenix, and we can speak with you in Spanish. Past results do not guarantee a similar outcome.
Joe’s career is distinguished by his exceptional leadership skills, success in managing teams, and the substantial results he has achieved for his clients. He led a Colorado office of over ten personal injury attorneys and played a pivotal role in the growth of a prominent personal injury firm, which expanded from two to over thirty attorneys under his tenure. His legal acumen has secured multiple seven-figure settlements in five different jurisdictions, highlighting his ability to deliver justice and significant compensation for his clients.
Years of experience: 16+ years
206 Wild Basin Rd. S.
Bldg. A, Ste. 204
Austin, Texas 78746
1580 Logan St
Suite 600
Denver, CO 80203
2325 E Camelback Rd
Suite 478
Phoenix, AZ 85016
Contact our law firm and find out how we can help you.
or call us at
512.351.7000